Pine Island Reserve, NC Vacation Rentals


Displaying - of results

  • Ocean Sands - J
  • More than 1000 feet
  • 6 beds (2 MBR)
  • 5 baths (1 half)
  • Sunday Check-In

$890 – $3,995/wk

  • Ocean Sands - J
  • More than 1000 feet
  • 5 beds (1 MBR)
  • 4 baths (1 half)
  • Sunday Check-In

$700 – $3,300/wk

  • Ocean Sands - J
  • More than 1000 feet
  • 5 beds (2 MBR)
  • 5 baths
  • Saturday Check-In

$790 – $3,650/wk


Want to see more homes?

You are currently searching for vacation rentals in Pine Island Reserve, NC only.
We have more homes that match your search in the OBX, outside of Pine Island Reserve.


Recent Pine Island Reserve Area Reviews


Leave it at the Door is an immaculate home with high quality finishes and amenities. It is ideally located and attached to a beautiful stretch of the beach, with private access and cabana service. The photos of the property are true advertisements; we were pleased to find the layout of the property and ocean view was better than expected. Overall, this property exceeded our expectations. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay, and plan to return to Leave it at the Door!

View home

Lindsay H.   •   September 28, 2016

Review for Leave it at the Door, in Pine Island Reserve, NC.


Mariner's Compass was a dream vacation experience. From the moment we arrived, we were in the lap of luxury in the middle of paradise. The great pride and care that both the homeowners and Twiddy paid to the property were evident our entire stay. Twiddly delivered a top notch vacation experience for our family, and the homeowners welcomed us with such graciousness. It was everything our family could have hoped for in an OBX vacation and more. We had such a fantastic time at Mariner's Compass, we have already booked again for next year. Thank you Mariner's Compass & Twiddy for making our week truly exceptional!

View home

Samantha S.   •   July 5, 2016

Review for Mariner's Compass, in Pine Island Reserve, NC.


We loved this house. We were there for my parents 50th Anniversary and were there as a group of 22. The views from windows in the main living room and the deck had amazing views. We saw dolphins from the window as soon as we arrived. The house had plenty of room for everyone to spread out but also had plenty of seating in the main room for everyone to be together too. We loved every minute of our vacation and will hopefully be returning next year.

View home

Stacey V.   •   May 18, 2016

Review for Good Day Sunshine, in Pine Island Reserve, NC.


This is a beautiful home, beautifully appointed. The house has common areas that were large enough to accommodate our group of 16, but also enough smaller areas so that everyone was able to find a place to be alone. The decorative choices throughout the house are thoughtful and elegant, and everything is in excellent repair. The beds are extremely comfortable, which is not always the case when one is away from home. The large kitchen was a joy to work in, and all 16 of us were able to eat together at the Papa Bear-sized dining table. We look forward to returning next year!

View home

Robin S.   •   October 4, 2015

Review for Story House, in Pine Island Reserve, NC.


We have stayed at this house for two years and are looking forward to our stay next year. The house is beautiful and very well furnished and equipped. It is the perfect house for a large family gathering. The pantry is wonderful and helps keep things neat and organized. The various seating areas allow people to mingle in smaller groups throughout the house. The kitchen downstairs is great for drink prep and cooking out. We love this house!

View home

Susan H.   •   July 12, 2015

Review for Good Day Sunshine, in Pine Island Reserve, NC.